Of Occam’s Razor and Natural Born Citizens, Part 1
“THE MOST STRINGENT AND IMPENETRABLE BARRIERS”
by Joseph DeMaio, ©2015
— In science and mathematics as well as in other disciplines, including political discourse, there is a principle known as
Occam’s razor.
Reduced to its essence, it articulates the proposition that the
simplest answer or explanation for a result is the one relying on the
fewest assumptions. Moreover, the principle postulates that such answer
or explanation will likely be the correct one.
image:
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgeuK8B85kw-50eDUDl5_Gnh4hT0qNiljfSgP9gqXdMfvz7rEoaVT9UvWAhP3mA7xCoqDnMPdEOLTcdTi-gSv3QRse1hQuY3vWHj_YvghNvokMA_PQqghE-twoL4mmhftgZUbu59ifBWYsn/s320/PE1-Signing-of-the-Constitution-450x295+op.jpg

If applied to the question of whether the Founding Fathers intended (a)
to restrict eligibility to the presidency to persons born here to two
parents, a father and a mother, who were at the time of birth already
U.S. citizens, or (b) open up eligibility to the presidency to any Tom,
Ted, Marco, Bobby, Hillary or Barack at all born here (or maybe not),
whether one, both or either of the parents was a U.S. citizen and
regardless of whether one, both or either of the parents were from
Yemen, Argentina or Kenya and whether here legally or illegally… which
one is more likely to be the correct answer?
The following refresher course “hints” that the more “wise and seasonable” answer – and more likely the correct one – is: “a.”
INTRODUCTION
In the continuing saga of who is – and who is not – eligible to serve as
president under the “natural born Citizen” clause of the Constitution,
Art. 2, Sec. 1, Cl. 5, it bears repeating that the U.S. Supreme Court
has not – repeat,
not – yet issued a binding decision on
the point. While numerous cases have tangentially addressed the issue
and/or strongly intimated a ruling on the question, none has yet
directly addressed the matter in the context of a sitting president or a
viable candidate to the office.
Moreover, while several lower court appellate cases have attempted to
raise the issue as to the current occupier of the White House, and,
ultimately, reach the Supreme Court for a decision, most have either
been dismissed for lack of “standing” in the plaintiff seeking an
adjudication of the matter or, even if abstract standing is recognized,
denied Supreme Court review by
certiorari. As to the denials of
certiorari,
as P&E readers well know, at least one Supreme Court Justice has
articulated the view that, as to the eligibility issue as it might
relate to current events, the Court “is
evading that issue.”
image: https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjWRMfav1e0EDSDpr7vAmUWNNfNQGUsLkUBQqmOR45rj49kgd03GFrgEbmpj5C55tvX4tiDR2J7FJNfntued02Fdps2qi9DFP6RoKJx1SFpN2mj4j4rwieNN0XqTQbO2h4HtX25AfD2THQi/s1600/PE2-The-Law-of-Nations1-201x300+op.png

Accordingly,
since the issue persists – and in light of recent attempts to “put to
rest” rumors that certain GOP presidential candidates may be, just as is
the current usurper of the office, ineligible to
hold the office
– it is prudent periodically to revisit several salient points
supporting the conclusion that the Founding Fathers intended that the
term “natural born Citizen” as used by them in the Constitution meant
only
those persons who, when born, were born to two parents who were both at
that time already citizens of this nation. This conclusion is
consistent with the teachings of Emmerich de Vattel in his tome, “
The Law of Nations” and specifically, § 212 thereof.
There, de Vattel articulates the principle of law that natural born
citizens “are those born in the country, of parents who are citizens…”
and that “…in order to be of the country, it is necessary that a person
be born of a father who is a citizen; for, if he is born there of a
foreigner, it will be only the place of his birth, and not his country.”
If one looks closely enough, there are numerous empirical facts
validating these principles and their impact on the Founders as they
drafted and ratified their new Constitution. These facts, of course,
are either ignored or trivialized by those seeking to allow anyone
(other than within the diplomat or military exceptions) simply born here
– Occam’s razor option “b” above – to be eligible to the presidency.
That is not, empirically speaking, what the Founders intended.
So, with apologies (as usual) for the length of this post, let us begin.
THE “NO CITIZEN PARENT/ONE CITIZEN PARENT” STANDARD VS. TWO CITIZEN PARENTS STANDARD
First, as noted
here,
it is undisputed the Founders were intent on erecting the most
stringent and impenetrable barriers available to thwart the entry into
the office of the presidency of foreigners and foreign influences. This
objective is clearly set forth in various of the notes emanating from
the constitutional convention as well as in the recognition of the
dangers associated with allowing the possibility of any foreign
influence to infiltrate or commandeer the office.
This concern is plainly articulated by Founding Father Alexander Hamilton in
Federalist, No. 68: “Nothing was more to be desired than that
every practicable obstacle
should be opposed to cabal, intrigue, and corruption. These most deadly
adversaries of republican government might naturally have been expected
to make their approaches from more than one quarter,
but chiefly
from the desire in foreign powers to gain an improper ascendant in our
councils. How could they better gratify this, than by raising a creature
of their own to the chief magistracy of the Union?” (Emphasis added).
Clearly, the objective and desire of the Founders was not to make it
merely “difficult” or “laborious” for a foreigner to access and ascend
to the office. Rather, consistent with erecting “every practical
obstacle” to foreign entry into the presidency, the objective was to
make it virtually impossible for that to happen. To that end, a
standard which requires both parents to be citizens at the time of birth
– rather than one or neither to be a citizen – presents a far more
fortified barrier than one that disregards the de Vattel “two citizen
parents” and at minimum, “citizen father” standards, both articulated in
§ 212 of his treatise.
Some have argued that, after the passage of the Fourteenth Amendment (1868) and the Supreme Court decision in
United States v. Wong Kim Ark,
169 U.S. 649 (1898), mere birth within this nation – regardless of the
citizenship of the parents (unless the parents are military or
diplomatic personnel of a foreign nation) – is “good enough” and will
suffice to constitute the person a “natural born Citizen” for
constitutional eligibility purposes.
Thus, under this theory, an “anchor baby” born to two alien non-citizens
merely present here from another country – whether Yemen, Argentina or
Kenya and whether here legally or illegally – would make the child a
“natural born Citizen” eligible to serve as president. Without regard
to the practical likelihood of that person being actually elected – an
issue
completely unrelated to constitutional eligibility – this
cannot be what the Founders intended. Chief among the advocates for
this expansive reading of the term are the lawyers at the Congressional
Research Service (“CRS”) (see, e.g.,
http://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R42097.pdf) as well as distinguished former attorneys with the Office of the United States
Solicitor General.
As noted by the U.S. Supreme Court in
Minor v. Happersett, 88
U.S. 162 (1875), while there have been doubts about claims to status as a
“natural born Citizen” regarding persons born to non-citizen parents,
there have “never” been any doubts as to such claims with respect to
persons born here to two citizen parents. See
Minor, 88 U.S. at 167-168.
image: https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEimA1Je2AIrD33Nn4ydqn1RV2_vnHGKabjjK6spIZfiLB6_1fE9p1wVA3B58id0CSsKVrXbZvm5dgSqLCm4stUtfSmZybCY-ERuLzMBdBoCcmwxByinqKWOIyTc63fn2oSHzi93ByPsEhrM/s1600/PE3-CRS-Logo+op.png

Even if that recognition by the Supreme Court be deemed non-binding
“dicta” as contended by the CRS lawyers – and persuasive arguments exist
that the Court’s recognition of that fact is not dicta, but instead a
necessary component of the holding in the case – it is nonetheless
“dicta” by the U.S. Supreme Court which clearly articulates a true,
empirical fact, as noted
here.
Accordingly, the notion that the Founders consciously intended to design and select a
lower standard of presidential eligibility (
e.g., the Yemeni anchor baby option) when a
higher standard
existed (§ 212, de Vattel) strains credibility and plainly turns the
intent of the Founders regarding insulation of the presidency from
foreigners and foreign influence on its head.
Indeed, under the “open borders” policies of the current regime, the CRS
interpretation of the eligibility clause converts the constitutional
barrier intended to be erected by the Founders into a “fast-track” lane
for the precise end they sought to avoid and prevent. For this reason
alone,
the expansive theory conflating “native born citizens” with “natural
born citizens” as advocated by the CRS and the former lawyers at the
Solicitor General’s Office is poorly reasoned and thus, intellectually
flawed.
Second, although the 2011 CRS “Report re: Qualifications for President and the ‘Natural Born’ Citizenship [
sic]
Eligibility Requirement” grudgingly cites the decision in
Minor,
it trivializes and minimizes the Court’s observation that there had
“never been doubts” with regard to the status of persons born here to
two citizen parents as being “natural born citizens.”
To its credit, however, the 2011 CRS Report at least does not delete from the Court’s
Minor
opinion by ellipsis omission this relevant language, contrary to its
practice later in the Report (p. 45) with regard to the Court’s decision
in
Perkins v. Elg, 307 U.S. 325, 329 (1939). As detailed
here, that grammatical chicanery was advanced by the 2011 CRS Report as well as in a prior 2009 CRS “
Memorandum”
in support of the counterfeited claim that even the children of alien
parents, if born here, constitute “natural born citizens.”
And while the 2011 CRS Report displays great skill in gathering
“cherry-picked” anecdotal evidence that its theory, rather than the “§
212 de Vattel theory,” better states the Founders’ intent, none of it is
based on the actual writings (as opposed to transcriptions of the
handwriting) of the Founders. In particular, none of the Report’s
anecdotal evidence bores more deeply into what John Jay intended when he
sent a July 25, 1787 letter to George Washington “hinting” that only a
“natural born citizen” should be eligible to the presidency.
Indeed, the 2011 CRS Report boldly (and erroneously) asserts that as to
the “§ 212 de Vattel” theory requiring two citizen parents at the time
of birth for the child to qualify, at that moment, as a natural born
citizen, “… there is no justification [for the two-citizen parent
requirement] … in any of the statements or writings of the framers of
the Constitution….”
See 2011 CRS Report at 46. Really? The CRS researchers might well have dug a bit deeper before making that assertion.
Accordingly, an examination of what John Jay meant when he used those words in his “hint” to Washington seems prudent.
JOHN JAY’S HINT
The writings of John Jay – a Founding Father, a contributor to The
Federalist and the first Chief Justice of the United States Supreme
Court – provide useful guidance. While there is apparently no specific
reference to § 212 of de Vattel’s work in the notes of the
Constitutional Convention or in the Federalist, later to become more
commonly known as “The Federalist Papers” – a work frequently cited by
the Supreme Court when seeking the Founders’ original intent – it is
generally acknowledged that the origin of the suggestion that the
“natural born Citizen” limitation be inserted into the draft
Constitution came as a result of a July 25, 1787 letter penned by
Founder John Jay to the chief presiding officer of the Constitutional
Convention in Philadelphia, George Washington.
Accordingly, one additional source worthy of examination regarding what
the Founders intended in using the term could lie in the contemporaneous
writings of the Founders, including, for example, John Jay, Thomas
Jefferson and James Madison. Jay and Madison, of course, were (along
with Alexander Hamilton) the “Publius” authors of The Federalist.
In the
letter most frequently quoted, the future first Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court writes to General Washington:
“Permit me to hint, whether it would not be wise and seasonable to
provide as a strong check to the admission of Foreigners into the
administration of our national government and to declare expressly that
the Command in Chief of the american army, shall not be given to, nor
devolve on, any but a natural
born Citizen.”
The original of the handwritten letter is now preserved in the Library
of Congress in Washington, D.C. Specifically, in Jay’s handwriting,
the word “american” is not capitalized, and the word “born” is
underscored. When those words are transcribed into print, most versions
capitalize the word “american,” but omit Jay’s underscoring of the word
“born.” Whether there is any significance to Jay’s underscoring of the
word “born,” in turn, might be gleaned from a prior
draft
of the latter dated the same day, which is preserved in the Columbia
University, Butler Library, Rare Book & Manuscript Division in New
York City, New York.
As can be seen from that image, while most of the language of the final,
original Library of Congress document delivered to George Washington
appears, much of it takes the form of interlineations of text following
the crossing out of previously existing text. What is unknown, of
course, is what the crossed-out text said before Jay substituted the
language we now see.
However, the “natural born Citizen” phrase first appearing in the
“Columbia” document image is exactly the same as that appearing in the
final “Library of Congress” image, with one important exception: while
the word “born” in the “Columbia” image is not underscored, the word “
born” is underscored in the final, Library of Congress image. This small difference merits further examination.
On the one hand, it might be argued that it is of no significance and
that Jay simply meant to emphasize that one must be actually born here
as opposed to being born elsewhere or being naturalized. On the other
hand, it might be argued that he intended to emphasize the core
principles embodied in § 212 of de Vattel’s work that, as stated there,
in order for one to be a natural
born citizen, one must be
born
in the country to “parents who are citizens” and/or, at minimum, born
to a father who is, at the time of birth, already a citizen. Otherwise –
as further specifically noted by de Vattel in the last sentence of §
212 – the country will be only the place of the child’s birth and not
the child’s country.
Thus, it is clear that under the de Vattel approach, a more restrictive
definition of “natural born Citizen” – requiring both parents to already
be citizens when the child is born – prevails over the less restrictive
definition advocated by the 2009 and 2011 CRS documents. So the
question becomes: would John Jay have favored a
more restrictive or a
less
restrictive barrier to the entry into the presidency of foreigners and
foreign influence? Moreover, would that preference have manifested
itself in his selection of the words “natural born citizen” in his
“hint?” The historical evidence suggests, clearly, that Jay would have
selected the more restrictive option over the more liberal option.
In support of this conclusion, it should be noted that after George
Washington submitted Jay’s “hint” to the participants at the
Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia, the actual language we now
see in Art. 2, Sec. 1, Cl. 5 appeared and was approved by the convention
delegates for final inclusion.
Thereafter, however, as the Constitutional Convention was nearing its
end, on July 25, 1788 – exactly one year following his “hint” to George
Washington – John Jay personally proposed an additional amendment to the
“natural born Citizen” requirement which would have
further narrowed
the field – rather than expanded the field – of eligible natural born
citizens to those who in addition were “freeholders,”
i.e., natural born citizens who
also held
title to land.
Specifically, the amendment Jay offered, and made a part of the
ratification process by his home state of New York, proposed an
amendment of the existing natural born citizen provision of the
Constitution approved by the convention to provide, among other things,
that presidential eligibility would be restricted to natural born
citizens “who shall be
Freeholders.”
This amendment seems plainly to support the conclusion that John Jay,
if faced with the Occam’s razor options discussed above, would choose
“a” and reject “b.” Rocket science, this is not.
However, Jay’s amendment also sought to extend the natural born citizen
“Freeholder” restriction to “Members of either House of the Congress of
the United States.” That amendment, as we know, failed, with the
delegates enacting the language of Art. 2, Sec. 1, Cl. 5 as we now see
it.
The point, however, is that the genesis of the Constitution’s natural
born citizen requirement – Jay’s July 25, 1787 “hint” to George
Washington – originated with a Founder who favored not only the
restriction on the eligibility to the presidency provided by that
concept as articulated by de Vattel in § 212, but who seemingly meant to
even further fortify the restriction with his “freeholder” amendment.
Some constitutional scholars have suggested that the amendment
ultimately failed because it sought to extend the natural born citizen
eligibility restriction to the
members
of the Congress. While the delegates were plainly in favor of
retaining the natural born citizen restriction for the chief executive,
extending the restriction to all the members of Congress may have been
seen as “a bridge too far.” If Jay’s amendment had passed, it likely
would have disqualified many members of Congress, including, for
example, Senator Harry Reid, both of whose parents were rumored to be
Klingons. Too bad it failed.
Thus, John Jay, in suggesting to George Washington that the presidency
should be restricted “only” to natural born citizens, seems clearly to
have intended the more restrictive definition of that term calculated to
erect a much higher bar to the entry of foreigners into the presidency –
option “a” – than the lower “option ‘b’” standard deemed by the CRS and
the former Solicitor General’s Office lawyers under the Constitution to
be “
refreshingly clear.”
——————-
[Part 2 to follow shortly.] (May 12, 2015) © 2015,
The Post & Email. All rights reserved. Source
link.